Indy Card Exchange Fishers

Reviews Summary :

Customer reviews for Indy Card Exchange highlight a welcoming atmosphere with friendly and knowledgeable staff who are passionate about helping collectors. Many visitors appreciate the expertise in card grading and detail-oriented service, which have resulted in high grading scores for their cards. However, the store’s focus is mainly on sports cards; customers seeking non-sports items, especially Pokémon cards, may find limited support and options. While collectors praise the diverse card selection appealing to various budgets, some have noted dissatisfaction with trade-in policies that are stricter for non-PSA graded cards and sealed products.

Prices :

Grading services: Starts at $23/card, Sports card singles: $1-$500+

Speciality :

Card grading and sports card collections

Tournament Schedule :

Not specified

Best for :

Collectors of sports cards and beginners looking for guidance

FAQ :

Does it have vintage pokemon cards ?

Yes, vintage cards are available

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have japanese products ?

Not specified

Does it have good single selection ?

Good selection, with a variety catering to all budgets

What is their trade in policy ?

Trade-ins primarily accepted for PSA graded cards only

Price match ?

Not specified

Is this store beginner friendly ?

Very welcoming to new players

Competitive scene and regular players ?

Active casual trading atmosphere, but limited tournament play

Yes, a solid community of sports card collectors

Is the staff knowledgeable in pokemon cards ?

Very knowledgeable about grading and sports cards

Pro tips :

Join the Kids Club for exclusive offers and activities if you’re a young collector.

Ask about grading services for your cards to maximize their value before selling.